Conflict of Interest Policy
JURNAL INDO-ISLAMIKA • PUBLICATION ETHICS
CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY
Jurnal Indo-Islamika
EDITORIAL COMMITMENT
Policy Statement
Jurnal Indo-Islamika, published by the Graduate School of UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta, Indonesia, recognizes that financial, professional, institutional, and personal relationships may affect, or reasonably be perceived to affect, the independence of scholarly judgment.
This policy establishes procedures for the identification, disclosure, evaluation, and management of competing interests involving authors, reviewers, editors, and other individuals participating in the journal's publication process.
A conflict of interest does not necessarily indicate unethical conduct or invalidate scholarly research. However, relevant interests must be disclosed transparently and managed appropriately to preserve confidence in editorial decisions and published findings.
ON THIS PAGE
Categories of Interests Author Disclosure Peer Review Editorial Recusal Conflict Management Funding Independence Post-Publication Declaration Examples Policies and ReferencesSECTION 01 • IDENTIFICATION OF INTERESTS
1. Categories of Competing Interests
For the purposes of this policy, a competing interest refers to a relationship, activity, commitment, or circumstance that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, an individual's scholarly judgment.
Relevant interests may include the following categories.
SECTION 03 • REVIEWER INDEPENDENCE
3. Competing Interests in Peer Review
Reviewers are expected to evaluate whether any professional, financial, personal, or institutional relationship could compromise their ability to provide an independent scholarly assessment.
Potential conflicts should be disclosed to the handling editor before accepting a review invitation or promptly upon becoming apparent.
A reviewer should decline or withdraw from an assignment when a significant competing interest cannot be appropriately managed.
Examples include close collaboration with an author, recent supervisory relationships, significant academic disputes, direct involvement in the research being evaluated, or a financial or professional interest in the manuscript's outcome.
Where uncertainty exists, the reviewer should consult the handling editor rather than independently assume that the relationship is irrelevant.
The handling editor should determine whether the declared circumstances permit an impartial review or require the appointment of another reviewer.
SECTION 04 • EDITORIAL INDEPENDENCE
4. Editorial Conflicts and Recusal
Editors and editorial board members must disclose interests relevant to manuscripts under their responsibility.
An editor should not participate in the assessment or final decision of a manuscript when a relationship or circumstance creates a substantial risk of bias.
Relevant situations may include manuscripts authored by close collaborators, family members, current research partners, or individuals with whom the editor has a significant competing interest.
Where an editor identifies such a conflict, responsibility for handling the manuscript should be transferred to another qualified editor who is not affected by the same conflict.
INDEPENDENT EDITORIAL HANDLING
Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members, or individuals closely associated with the journal must be evaluated through an independent editorial arrangement.
The submitting editor should not select reviewers, access confidential reviewer recommendations beyond what is necessary in the capacity of an author, or participate in decisions concerning their own manuscript.
Editorial assignment and recusal decisions should be documented internally to support procedural accountability.
SECTION 05 • MANAGEMENT PROCEDURES
5. Assessment and Management of Disclosed Interests
Disclosure does not automatically result in manuscript rejection or exclusion from scholarly participation.
When a competing interest is declared, the editorial team should assess its relevance and potential influence on the research, review process, or editorial decision.
Appropriate management measures may include:
COMPETING INTEREST MANAGEMENT MEASURES
|
01
|
Recording and acknowledging the disclosed interest. |
|
02
|
Requesting additional clarification or supporting information. |
|
03
|
Publishing an appropriate declaration alongside the accepted article. |
|
04
|
Appointing an independent reviewer or handling editor. |
|
05
|
Excluding a conflicted individual from a particular editorial decision. |
|
06
|
Seeking independent advice when the circumstances require additional scrutiny. |
Management decisions should be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the identified interest.
The journal should distinguish between a relationship that can be managed through transparent disclosure and a conflict that requires withdrawal from the relevant editorial activity.
SECTION 06 • RESEARCH FUNDING TRANSPARENCY
6. Funding Influence and Research Independence
Research sponsorship and institutional support do not automatically invalidate scholarly findings.
Nevertheless, financial supporters, sponsoring organizations, and collaborating institutions should not exercise undisclosed control over research interpretation or publication decisions.
Where a sponsor has participated in research design, data collection, analysis, manuscript preparation, or decisions concerning publication, that involvement should be disclosed when relevant.
Authors should clarify any contractual or institutional restrictions that may materially affect independent analysis, access to research evidence, or the dissemination of findings.
The editorial team may request further information when the nature of a sponsoring relationship raises substantial questions concerning scholarly independence.
SECTION 07 • POST-PUBLICATION TRANSPARENCY
7. Undisclosed Interests Identified After Publication
If a relevant competing interest is identified after publication, the editorial team should assess whether the omission affects the transparency, interpretation, or reliability of the published article.
The assessment should consider the nature of the relationship, its relevance to the published research, the explanation provided by the individuals concerned, and whether the information could reasonably influence a reader's evaluation of the article.
Where the issue concerns an incomplete or inaccurate declaration, the journal may publish an appropriate clarification or correction.
More substantial concerns should be evaluated under the journal's relevant procedures for research integrity and post-publication editorial action.
An omitted declaration does not automatically establish that the research findings are invalid.
SECTION 08 • AUTHOR DECLARATION FORMATS
8. Conflict of Interest Statements in Published Articles
To ensure consistent reporting, Jurnal Indo-Islamika recommends including a clearly identifiable Conflict of Interest statement in the final manuscript.
The following examples illustrate appropriate declaration formats.
These examples may be adapted to reflect the specific circumstances of each submission. Declarations must be accurate and must not be used to conceal material relationships.
SECTION 09 • POLICY INTEGRATION
9. Policy Implementation and References
This policy provides detailed guidance on competing interests and should be read alongside the journal's existing Publication Ethics and related editorial policies.
RELATED JOURNAL POLICIES
Publication Ethics:
https://journal.uinjkt.ac.id/index.php/indo-islamika/PublicationEthicsAuthor Guidelines:
https://journal.uinjkt.ac.id/index.php/indo-islamika/AuthorGuidelinesEditorial Contact:
https://journal.uinjkt.ac.id/index.php/indo-islamika/about/contactINTERNATIONAL PUBLICATION ETHICS
International Reference Framework
REFERENCE 01 • ICMJE
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Disclosure of Financial and Non-Financial Relationships and Activities, and Conflicts of Interest.
https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/REFERENCE 02 • COPE
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
https://doi.org/10.24318/2019.1.4Jurnal Indo-Islamika is committed to the transparent identification and proportionate management of competing interests so that research evaluation and editorial decision-making remain independent, credible, and accountable.
JURNAL INDO-ISLAMIKA
Graduate School, UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta
P-ISSN 2088-9445 | E-ISSN 2723-1135
CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY




