Post-Publication Discussion

AHKAM: Jurnal Ilmu Syariah encourages constructive academic dialogue and scholarly engagement concerning articles published in the journal. The journal recognizes post-publication discussion as an important mechanism for strengthening academic debate, promoting critical inquiry, and maintaining the quality and integrity of scholarly publications.

1. Submission of Comments and Letters to the Editor

Readers, researchers, and members of the academic community may submit formal Letters to the Editor or Comments concerning previously published articles. Submissions may address significant findings, theoretical arguments, legal interpretations, research methodologies, analytical approaches, or other relevant issues requiring clarification or further academic discussion.

All submissions must be written in a professional and constructive manner, supported by relevant scholarly arguments and references, and must comply with the journal's author guidelines and publication ethics.

2. Authors' Right to Respond

When a comment or letter concerning a published article is considered suitable for publication, the original author(s) will be given an opportunity to submit a formal Response or Rebuttal.

The response should address the issues raised objectively and provide appropriate scholarly explanations, clarifications, or counterarguments. Both the submitted comment and the author's response may undergo peer review or editorial assessment, as determined by the Editorial Board.

3. Editorial Assessment and Publication

All submissions for post-publication discussion are subject to editorial evaluation to ensure their academic relevance, originality, accuracy, and compliance with publication ethics.

AHKAM may publish comments, letters, and corresponding author responses when they contribute meaningfully to scholarly discourse and the advancement of knowledge in Islamic law and related disciplines.

The Editorial Board reserves the right to request revisions or decline submissions that do not meet the journal's academic and ethical standards.

Through this policy, AHKAM: Jurnal Ilmu Syariah seeks to foster an open, critical, and respectful academic environment while promoting the continuous development of Islamic legal scholarship.