Ethical Clearance Approval

Ethical Research Standards

Ethical Clearance Approval

Ensuring responsible research involving human participants, animals, and ethically sensitive biological materials.

Policy Statement

Jurnal Kimia VALENSI, published by the Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science and Technology, UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta, requires authors to comply with applicable ethical principles and institutional requirements in the design, implementation, and reporting of research.

Authors reporting research involving human or animal interventions must submit an ethical clearance document issued by an authorized ethics committee together with their manuscript. This document serves as evidence that the study underwent appropriate ethical review.

Human Research

Requires applicable ethical approval for research involving interventions with human participants.

Animal Research

Requires applicable ethical approval for experimental interventions involving animals.

Other Chemical Research

Ethics approval depends on the study design and applicable institutional or regulatory requirements.

1. Research Requiring Ethical Clearance

Ethical clearance is required under this policy for manuscripts reporting human or animal interventions. Research in chemistry and related fields that may involve ethics review includes:

  • Experimental studies involving human participants.
  • Studies administering, testing, or evaluating chemical compounds, formulations, or interventions in humans.
  • Animal experiments involving drugs, extracts, chemicals, toxicity testing, or biological interventions.
  • Experimental pharmacological or toxicological research involving live animals.
  • Other studies requiring ethics committee approval under applicable institutional or legal rules.

Studies involving human-derived biological samples, medical records, or identifiable health information may also require ethical approval, consent, or an authorized exemption or waiver, depending on the study design and governing requirements.

2. Ethical Clearance Documentation

For studies requiring ethical approval, authors must provide documentation from an authorized research ethics committee. The documentation should identify, where available:

  1. The official name of the approving ethics committee.
  2. The institution issuing the approval.
  3. The ethics approval number or reference code.
  4. The approval date.
  5. The approved research title or protocol identification.
  6. Relevant approval conditions, where applicable.
Submission Requirement

Where ethical clearance is required, the approval document must accompany the manuscript submission. Editors may request additional clarification or supporting documentation during the editorial evaluation.

3. Ethical Information in the Manuscript

Authors should include an appropriate ethics statement in the Research Methods section or a separate declarations section. The statement should identify the approving committee, approval reference, and other relevant ethical conditions.

Examples of Ethics Statements
Human Research

"This study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of [institution] (Approval No. [number], dated [date]). Informed consent was obtained from participants where required."

Animal Research

"The animal experimental procedures were approved by [ethics committee/institution] (Approval No. [number], dated [date]) and conducted in accordance with applicable animal welfare requirements."

Research Not Requiring Ethics Committee Approval

"This study did not involve human or animal interventions. Ethics committee approval was not required under the applicable institutional requirements."

These are illustrative statements. Authors must report the actual ethical status of their research and must not invent approval numbers, committee names, or exemptions.

4. Informed Consent and Research Participant Protection

Where applicable, research involving human participants must comply with requirements concerning informed consent, confidentiality, privacy, and participant safety. Authors must ensure that identifiable personal or medical information is not disclosed without appropriate authorization.

For animal studies, authors should describe relevant experimental procedures and demonstrate compliance with applicable animal welfare standards and ethics committee conditions.

5. Research Not Involving Human or Animal Interventions

Many chemistry studies, such as chemical synthesis, instrumental analysis, computational modeling, environmental sampling, and materials characterization, do not automatically require human or animal research ethics approval.

Nevertheless, researchers remain responsible for complying with applicable laboratory safety, chemical handling, environmental protection, sample collection, biosafety, and institutional requirements.

Where the applicability of ethical approval is uncertain, authors should consult their institution or authorized ethics committee. An official exemption or waiver should be reported where one has been issued.

6. Editorial Assessment and Noncompliance

The Editorial Team may verify ethics documentation and request clarification concerning applicable approval, consent, or research conduct requirements.

  • Manuscripts lacking required ethics documentation may be held pending clarification.
  • Authors may be asked to provide an approval letter or appropriate institutional confirmation.
  • Research with serious or unresolved ethical deficiencies may be rejected.
  • Concerns discovered after publication may be examined under the journal's misconduct and corrective-action policies.
Commitment to Ethical Research

Jurnal Kimia VALENSI promotes responsible scientific research that respects ethical review requirements, protects research participants, and supports the humane treatment of animals used in research.

Related guidance: Publication Ethics   |   Editorial Contact