Government Liability to Damages Due to Defective Provision of Health Services in Turkey
Abstract
Health service is one of the essential public services offered by the Administration with a very comprehensive and expansive staff, and due to the comprehensive nature of the service provided and the fact that the beneficiaries of the service constitute almost every segment of society, many different appearances of defect that may include the compensation responsibility of the Administration may arise. Therefore, the study is mainly about the service defect and the compensation responsibility of the Administration in providing health services within the scope of the responsibility of the Administration based on service defect. In the study, the concept of the responsibility of the Administration and the concepts of defect liability and strict liability, which are the types of responsibility of the Administration, will be discussed first. All will examine the conditions of the responsibility of the Administration. Then, the concept of service defects and the different appearances of service defects, such as poor service, late service, non-operational service, and severe service defect, will be examined. Finally, the service defects specific to health services, which constitute the main framework of the study, will be discussed in light of the decisions of the Council of State on this issue.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Akgul, A. (2016). Responsibility for Compensation of the Administration arising from Health Services and The New Approach of the State Council Journal of Ankara Hacı Bayram Veli University Faculty of Law, 20 (1), 269-302.
Akyilmaz, B. (2011). Public Damage and Recourse in Public Damage. Journal of Istanbul University Law Faculty, 69(1-2), 61-78.
Akyılmaz, B., Sezginer, M. & Kaya, C. (2019). Turkish Law of Administration Ankara, Turkey: SavaşPublishing House.
Altunkaya, M., Guloglu, Y., Belkayali, N., Bulut, A. & Cesur, İ. (2020). Liability for Damage Caused by Domestic and Wild Animals in Turkish Law. Jurnal Cita Hukum, 8(2), 243-260.
Anayurt, O. (1989). "Fault-Based Responsibility of the Administration in Turkish Law", Unpublished Master's Thesis, Gazi University Institute of Social Sciences, Ankara.
Atay, E. E. (2009). Administrative Law, Turhan Bookstore, Ankara.
Atay, E. E. (2010). Odabasi, Hasan. Liability of the Administration and Compensation Cases, Seçkin Publishing House, Ankara.
Ayan, M. (1991). Legal Liability Arising From Medical Interventions.
Belkayali, N., & Güloğlu, Y. (2019). Physical and Social Barriers For Disabled Urban Park Users: Case Study From Kastamonu, Turkey. Forestist, 69(1), 35-43.
Capraz, N., Tapan, B., & Dikmen, C. (2012). Implementation Principles of Compulsory Liability Insurance Regarding Medical Malpractice on the Basis of Countries and Turkey Practice.
Çıtak, H. A. (2014). Social Risk Principle In The Context Of The Strict Responsibility Of The Administration. Justice Publisher.
Değdaş, U. C. (2018). Civil and Criminal Liability Arising From Malpractice. Journal of Anadolu University Faculty of Law, 4(6), 41-65.
Duran, L. (1974). Responsibility Of The Turkish Administration: Basis And Reasons For Responsibility, Facts Leading To Liability (No. 138). Sevinc Press.
Eren, F. (2014). Law of Obligations, General Provisions, 16th Edition, Ankara.
Gözler, K. (2009). Administrative Law: Volume II, Ekin Publication.
Gözübüyük, A. Ş., & Tan, T. (2016). Administrative Law: General Principles. Turhan Bookstore.
Gulan, A. (1988). Public Service Concept. Journal of Administrative Law and Sciences, 9(1-3), 147-159.
Gulan, A. (2006). Patient and Physician Rights in terms of Medical Law. Ankem Magazine, 20, 16-19.
Guloglu, N. V. (2017). Transformation of Kufr into Action and Its Results as a Reaction to the Recitation of the Qur'an. Uludag University Journal of Theology Faculty, 26(2), 203-236.
Guloglu, N. V. (2020). Recitation in the Qur'an, Emin Publications, Bursa.
Güloğlu, Y., & Belkayalı, N. (2022). Architectural and Legal Control in the Context of Aesthetics , (39), 115-138.
Güloğlu, Y., Belkayalı, N. & Bulut, A. (2017). Is İt Legally Possible To Set Forest Fires For Scientific Purposes?, Kastamonu University Journal Of Forestry Faculty, 17(3): 491-501.
Güloğlu, Y., Belkayalı, N., Cesur, İ., & Bulut, A. (2018). Judıcıal Revıews Of Environmental Impact Of Hydroelectric Power Plants. Journal of Akdeniz University Faculty of Law, 8(2), 67-89.
Güloğlu, Y., Cesur, İ., & Bulut, A. (2022). Legal Responsibility Of The Forest Administration In Occupational Accidents In Forests. Suggestion Journal, 17(58), 549-575.
Gunday, M. (2011). Administrative law. Image Publishing House, 10th Edition, Ankara.
Guran, S. (1982). Responsibility of the State for the Physician's Activities. Journal of the Council of State, 12(46-47), 16-22.
Hakeri, H. (2021). Medical Law (23rd Edition). Ankara: Seçkin Publishing.
Hızal, A. & Çınarlı, S. (2015). Scope of Indemnity Obligation in Full Justice Cases Resulting from Malpractice. Journal of Istanbul Medipol University Faculty of Law, 2 (1), 143-185.
Kaplan, G. (2004). New Developments in the Field of Legal Responsibility of the Administration Resulting from the Execution of the Health Public Service. Journal of the Military Supreme Administrative Court, 19(1), 173-199.
Karaege, O. (2001). Faulty Liability of the Administration in Health Services. Journal of Management and Economics, 8(2), 107-124.
Kizilyel, S. (2008). "Rethinking the Concept of Fault in Health Care", Libra Law Review
Odyakmaz, Z., Kaymak, Ü., & Ercan, İ. (2008). Constitutional Law: Administrative Law. Second Edition.
Oguzman, M. K., & Oz, M. T. (2014). Law of obligations: general provisions: According to the new Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098. Vedat Bookstore.
Onar, S. S. (1966). General Principles of Administrative Law, III. Volume, Third Edition, Istanbul.
Ozay, I. H. (2011). Management in Daylight, Third Edition.
Ozguldur, S. (1996). Full Remedy Cases İn The Light Of The Decisions of the Military High Administrative Court. Seçkin Publishing
Özkan, H., & Akyıldız, S. Ö. (2008). Annotated, Case-Law Patient, Physician Rights And Lawsuits. Seçkin Bookstore.
Polat, O. (2019). Medical Practice Errors (3rd Edition). Ankara: Seçkin Publishing
Sancakdar, O., Us, E., Önüt, L. B., & Kasapoğlu Turhan, M. (2021). Administrative Law Theoretical Workbook. Seçkin Bookstore.
Sarıca, R. (1949). Fault of Service and Its Characteristics. Journal of Istanbul University Law Faculty, 15(4), 858-895.
Sarsıkoglu, S. (2016). The Concept Of Loss İn Terms Of The Financial Responsibility Of The Administration. Journal of Ankara University Faculty of Law, 65(4), 2389-2422.
Şen, Ö. (2021). The Concept of Damage and Compensation Calculation in Full Justice Cases Adalet Publishing House Ankara.
Türkoğlu Üstün, K. (2019). Principles Governing Administrative Procedure. Ankara: Seçkin Publishing.
Unlucay, M. (1998). Compensation Debt of the Administration and Inflation Phenomenon. Journal of the Council of State, (94), 3-10.
Yalçın, H., & Şahin, A. (2017). Law Of Liabılıty And Mandatory Professional Liability Insurance Regarding Medical Impossibility: An Implementation On Turkey. Çukurova University Journal Of Social Sciences Institute, 26(2), 45-56.
Yasin M. (2015). Confirmation In Administrative Trial Procedure, Istanbul, Turkey, On İki Levha Publication.
Yasin, M. & Şahin, C. (2015), Urbanization Law, On İki Levha Publication.
Zabunoğlu, Y. K., (2012). Administrative Law, Yetkin Publishing.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 07.07.2020 numbered E:2019/3811, K:2020/2667
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 08.12.2009 numbered E:2009/7969, K:2009/10233.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 09.04.2008 numbered E:2007/8357, K:2008/2064
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 13.10.2006 numbered E:2003/4864, K:2006/5652.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 17.4.2012 numbered E:2008/8441, K:2012/1544.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 20.03.2012 numbered E:2008/2688, K:2012/1006.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 20.03.2012 numbered E:2008/2688, K:2012/1006.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 24.09.2007numbered E:2005/3719, K:2007/4316
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 27.03.2007 numbered E:2007/5793, K:2007/1524
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 27.10.2009 numbered E:2007/305, K:2009/9183.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 27.10.2021 numbered E:2019/3811, K:2020/2667
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 27.10.2021 numbered E:2019/6676, K:2021/5188
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 27.10.2021 numbered E:2019/6676, K:2021/5188
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 27.3.2002 numbered E:2004/6540, K:2007/4237.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 28.02.2007 numbered E:2007/8645, K:2011/1570.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 30.06.2006 numbered 2004/10337 E. 2006/4726 K.
th Supreme Court Its decision numbered 2014/10131 ve 2014/34506 K.
th Supreme Court Its decision numbered 2014/17432 E. ve 2015/8358 K.
th Supreme Court Its decision numbered E. 2001/10959, K. 2002/487
th Supreme Court Its decision numbered E. 2002/7925, K. 2002/10687
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 11.03.2015 numbered E: 2013/7669 K:2015/1396.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 11.03.2015 numbered E: 2013/7669 K:2015/1396.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 15.04.2015 numbered E:2014/5076 K:2015/2184.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 18.02.2015 numbered E:2013/4361, K:2015/890.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 18.06.2015 numbered E:2014/9364, K:2015/4241.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 21.04.2015numbered E:2014/5867, K:20145/2320
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 21.04.2015 numbered E:2014/5867, K:2015/2320
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 21.05.2014numbered E: 2013/4135 K:2014/3970.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 23.09.2014 numbered E:2013/4079, K:2014/6453.
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 25.06.2015 numbered E:2014/8633, K:2015/4625
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 25.06.2015numbered E:2013/6275, K:2015/4430
th Chamber of the Council of State Its decision dated 30.05.2016 numbered E:2015/2607, K:2016/3893.
Supreme Court Assembly of Civil chambers Its decision numbered 29.03.2006 E.2006/4-86 K.2006/111
DOI: https://doi.org/10.15408/jch.v10i3.28014 Abstract - 0 PDF - 0
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
License URL: http://journal.uinjkt.ac.id/index.php/citahukum/index
