Religious Pluralism Revisited: Discursive Patterns of the Ulama Fatwa in Indonesia and Malaysia

Syafiq Hasyim


As a long-established fundamental value of both Indonesia and Malaysia, religious pluralism has become a highly contested issue. A common tendency among the dominant Muslim groups in Indonesia and Malaysia, promoted by their fatwa bodies, has been to revisit religious pluralism. This article poses questions: how pluralism is defined, discussed and contested in both countries; why mainstream Islamic groups reconstruct the meaning of the term; which arguments are used by these groups; and what impact this has on legal discourse and legal practice in both countries. With these questions, this article focuses on fatwas issued by the Indonesian Council of Ulama and the National Fatwa Council of Malaysia. The article discusses the incorporation of fatwas into state policy in both countries, social disputes and contestation over fatwas. The theoretical frameworks used are taken from interdisciplinary discourses on transnationalism, pluralism, Islamic legal theory, legal pluralism and the public sphere.


Religious Pluralism; Sharia; Fatwa; Indonesia; Malaysia

Full Text:



Abdelsalam, Ahmed. 2005. “The Practice of Violence in the Ḥisba Theories.” Iranian Studies 38(4): 547–54.

Assyaukanie, Lutfi. 2009. “Fatwa and Violence in Indonesia.” Journal of Religion and Society 2: 1–21.

Baxter, Hugh. 2011. The Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy. California: Stanford University Press.

Bayat, Asef. 2007a. Islam and Democracy: What Is the Real Question? Amsterdam University Press.

———. 2007b. Making Islam Democratic: Social Movements and the Post-Islamist Turn. Stanford University Press.

Berman, Paul Schiff. 2012. Legal Pluralism: A Jurisprudence of Law Beyond Borders. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Bowen, John. 2005. “Normative Pluralism in Indonesia: Regions, Religions, and Ethnicities.” In Multiculturalism in Asia, eds. Kymlicka Will and Baogang He. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 152–69.

Bruinessen, Martin van. 2009. “Liberal and Progressive Voices in Indonesian Islam.” In Reformist Voices of Islam, Mediating Islam and Modernity, ed. Shireen T Hunter. New York & London: Routledge, 187–207.

Cammileri, Rita. 2013. “Religious Pluralism in Malaysia: The Journey of Three Prime Ministers.” Islam and Christian–Muslim Relations 24(2).

Cook, Michael. 2003. Forbidding Wrong in Islam: An Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Eck, Diana L. 2010. “Is Our God Listening? Exclusivism, Inclusivism, and Pluralism.” In Islam and Global Dialogue: Religious Pluralism and the Pursuit of Peace, ed. Roger Boase. Burlington: Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 21–50.

Embong, Abdur Rahman. 2001. “The Culture and Practice of Pluralism in Post Colonial Malaysia.” In The Politics of Multiculturalism: Pluralism and Citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia, ed. Robert W. Hefner. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 59–85.

Fenwick, Stewart. 2016. “Faith and Freedom in Indonesian Law, Liberal Pluralism, Religion and the Democratic State.” In Religion, Law and Intolerance in Indonesia, New York: Routledge.

Filaly-Ansari, Abdou. 2009. “Introduction: Theoretical Approaches to Cultural Diversity.” In The Challenge of Pluralism: Paradigms from Muslim Contexts, eds. Abdou Filali-Ansary and Sikeena Karmali Ahmed. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1–8.

Fraser, Nancy. 1992. “Rethinking the Public Sphere: Contribution to the Critique of Actually Existing Democracy.” In Habermas and the Public Sphere, ed. Craig J Colhoun. MIT Press, 109–43.

Friedman, Friedman. 1989. “The Dialogue of Touchstones as an Approach to Interreligious Dialogue.” In Dialogue and Syncretism, An Interdiscplinary Approach, eds. Jerald D Gort, Hendrik M Vroom, Rein Fernhout, and Anton Wessels. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 76–84.

G25 Malaysia. 2016. Breaking The Silence: Voices of Moderation: Islam in a Constitutional Democracy. Singapore: Marshall Cavendish International.

Guan, Yeoh Seng. 2011. “Actually Existing Religious Pluralism in Kuala Lumpur.” In ISA.

Hadiz, Vedi R. 2014. “A New Islamic Populism and the Contradictions of Development.” Journal of Contemporary Asia 44(1): 125–43.

———. 2016. Islamic Populism in Indonesia and the Middle East. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hasani, Ismail, and Bonar Tigor Naipospos. 2011. Wajah Para Pembela Islam. Jakarta: Pustaka Masyarakat Setara.

Hasyim, Syafiq. 2014. “Council of Indonesian Ulama (Majelis Ulama Indonesia, MUI) and Its Role in the Shariatisation of Indonesia.” Free University.

———. 2015. “Majelis Ulama Indonesia and Pluralism in Indonesia.” Philosophy and Social Criticism 41(4–5): 487–495.

———. 2016. “The Council of Indonesian Ulama (MUI) and Aqīda-Based Intolerance, A Critical Analysis of Its Fatwa on Ahmadiyah and ‘Sepilis.’” In Religion, Law and Intolerance in Indonesia, eds. Tim Lindsey and Helen Pausacker. London.

Hefner, Robert W. 2001a. “Introduction: Multiculturalism and Citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia.” In The Politics of Multiculturalism, Pluralism and Citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia, ed. Robert W Hefner. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1–58.

Hefner, Robert W. 2001b. “Introduction: Multiculturalism and Citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia.” In The Politics of Multiculturalism, Pluralism and Citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia, ed. Robert W. Hefner. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1–58.

———. 2011. Civil Islam: Muslims and Democratization in Indonesia. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

Holst, Frederik. 2012. Ethnicization and Identity Construction in Malaysia. New York: Routledge.

Horowitz, Donald L. 2013. Constitutional Change and Democracy in Indonesia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ibn Taymiyya. 1992. Al-Hisbah Fi al-Islam Aw Wadifah al-Hukumah al-Islamiyyah. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah.

Ichwan, Moch Nur. 2013. “Contemporary Developments in Indonesian Islam: Explaining the ‘Conservative Turn.’” In Contemporary Developments in Indonesian Islam: Explaining the “Conservative Turn,” Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 60–104.

Intan, Benyamin Fleming. 2006. Public Religion And the Pancasila-Based State of Indonesia: An Ethical And Sociological Analysis. New York: Peter Lang.

Jahroni, Jajang. 2008. Defending the Majesty of Islam: Indonesia’s Front Pembela Islam, 1998-2003. Bangkok: Asian Muslim Action Network.

JAKIM. 2015. Kompilasi Pandangan Hukum Mudhākarah Jawatankuasa Fatwa Majlis Kebangsaan Bagi Hal Ehwal Ugama Islam Malaysia. Selangor: JAKIM.

Kasan, Hasnan. 2008. Institusi Fatwa Di Malaysia. Bangi: Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.

Krishnan, Loganathan. 2010. “The Antithesis between Civil Law and Islamic Law in a Pluralistic Society.” Shariah Journal 18(2): 401–14.

Lindsey, Tim. 2012. “Monopolising Islam? The Indonesian Ulama Council and State Regulation of the ‘Islamic Economy.’” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 48(2): 253–74.

Liow, Joseph Chinyong. 2009. Piety and Politics: Islamism in Contemporary Malaysia. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.

Majid, M K A. 2012. Wasatiyyah Islam: Antara Liberalisme & Konservatisme Di Malaysia. Pekan Ilmu Publications.

Mandaville, Peter G. 2002a. 2002 Transnational Muslim Politics: Reimagining the Umma. Mandaville, Peter: Routledge.

———. 2002b. 2002 Transnational Muslim Politics: Reimagining the Umma. London & New York: Routledge.

McKnight, C.J. 1996. “Pluralism, Realism and Truth.” In Philosophy and Pluralism, ed. David Archard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 87–100.

Middell, Matthias. 2014. “Is There a Timetable When Concepts Travel? On Syncronicity in the Emergence of New Concepts Dealing with Border Crossing Phenomena.” In The Trans/National Study of Culture, A Translational Perspective, eds. Doris Bachmann-Medick, Horst Carl, Wolfgang Hallet, and Ansgar Nuenning. Berlin: De Gruyter, 137–57.

Mietzner, Marcus. 2018. “Fighting Illiberalism with Illiberalism: Islamist Populism and Democratic Deconsolidation in Indonesia.” 91(2): 261–82.

Monsma, Stephen V., and J. Christopher Soper. 2009. The Challenge of Pluralism: Church and State in Five Democracies. Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield.

MUI. 2011. Himpunan Fatwa MUI Sejak 1975. Jakarta: Erlangga.

———. Mengawal Aqidah Umat: Fatwa MUI Tentang Aliran-Aliran Sesat Di Indonesia. Jakarta: Sekretariat Majelis Ulama Indonesia.

Noor, Farish A. 2009. “Reformist Muslim Thinkers in Malaysia Engaging with Power to Uplift the Umma?” In Reformist Voices of Islam, Mediating Islam and Modernity, ed. Shireen T Hunter. New York & London: Routledge, 208–26.

———. 2014. The Malaysian Islamic Party PAS 1951-2013. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.

Phan, Peter C, and Jonathan Ray, eds. 2014. Understanding Religious Pluralism: Perspectives from Religious Studies and Theology. Oregon: Pickwick Publications.

Ramage, Douglas. 2005. Politics in Indonesia, Democracy, Islam and the Ideology of Tolerance. London & New York: Routledge.

Rawls, John. 2011. Political Liberalism: Expanded Edition. New York: Columbia University Press.

Report, The Commanwelth Office. 2013. Human Rights and Democracy: The 2012 Foreign and Commonwealth Office Report. London: The Stationery Office.

Rosele, Muhammad Ikhlas, Luqman Hj Abdullah, Paizah Hj Ismail, and Mohd Anuar Ramli. 2013. “Konflik Fatwa Di Malaysia: Satu Kajian Awal.” Jurnal Fiqih (10): 31–56.

Said, Edward S. 1983. The World, the Text, and the Critic. Cambridge & Massachusset: Harvard University Press.

Sajoo, Amyn B. 1994. Pluralism in Old Societies and New States, Emerging ASEAN Contexts. Singapore.

Shuaib, Farid S. “The Islamic Legal System in Malaysia.” Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal 21(1): 85–113.

Shukri, Abdus Salam Muhamad, and Mohd Abbas Abdol Razak. 2018. “A Discourse on Religious Pluralism: A Short Survey.” AL-ITQAN, Journal of Islamic Sciences and Comparative Studies 2(2): 43–63.

Stephan, Alfrend, and Mirjam Kuenkler, eds. Democracy and Islam in Indonesia. New York: Columbia University Press.

Suaedy, Ahmad. 2009. “Islam, Negara Bangsa Dan Kebebasan Beragama.” In Merayakan Kebebasan Beragama: Bunga Rampai Menyambut 70 Tahun Djohan Effendi, ed. Elza Peldi Taher. Jakarta: Penerbit Buku Kompas, 410–23.

Suryadinata, Leo. 2018. Pancasila in the Challenge of Political Islam: Past and Present. Singapore.

Tagore, Saranindranath. 2010. “Rawlsian Liberalism, Secularism, and the Call for Cosmopolitanism.” In State and Securalism: Perspective from Asia, eds. Michael Heng Siam-Heng and Ten Chin Liew. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd., 37–59.

Taymiyya, Ibn. 1983. Al-Siyasah al-Shar’iyyah Fi Islah al-Ra’i Wa al-Ra’iyah. Beirut: Dar al-Afaq al-Jadidah.

Tie, Warwick. 1999. Legal Pluralism: Toward a Multicultural Conception of Law. London: Ashgate/Dartmouth.

Wagemakers, Jaos. 2011. “The Transformation of a Radical Concept: Al-Wala’ Wa al-Bara’ in the Ideology of Abu Muhammad al-Maqdisi.” In Global Salafism: Islam’s New Religious Movement, ed. Roel Meijer. New York: Columbia University Press, 81–106.

Watson, CW. 1996. “The Construction of the Post Colonial Subject in Malaysia.” In Asian Forms of the Nation, eds. Stein Tonnesson and Hans Antlov. London & New York: Routledge, 297–322.

Widiyanto, Asfa. 2016. Religious Authority and the Prospects of Religious Pluralism in Indonesia. Berlin: LIT.

Zaini, Nasohah. 2005. “Undang-Undang Penguatkuasaan Fatwa Di Malaysia.” Islāmiyyāt 27(1): 25–44.

Zubaida, Sami. 2009. “The Public and the Private in Middle Eastern History and Society.” In The Challenge of Pluralism: Paradigms from Muslim Contexts, eds. Abdou Filaly-Ansari and Sikeena Karmali Ahmed. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 16–32.

DOI: Abstract - 0 PDF - 0


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
All publication by Studia Islamika are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Studia Islamika, ISSN: 0215-0492, e-ISSN: 2355-6145

View My Stats