Publication Ethics

Publication Ethics & Malpractice Statement

Relations: Journal of Media Studies and Public Relations follows the standards and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), particularly in addressing research misconduct, publication malpractice, and ethical complaints. The journal is committed to ensuring integrity, transparency, and accountability throughout the editorial and publication process.

If the publisher, editors, reviewers, or readers become aware of any allegation of research or publication misconduct, the journal will handle such cases in accordance with COPE guidance and established best practices in scholarly publishing. The journal also adheres to the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing .

1. Journal Policies on Authorship and Contributorship

1.1 Authorship

Authors submitting to Relations: Journal of Media Studies and Public Relations must comply with internationally recognized authorship standards. Authorship should be based on all of the following criteria:

  1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data; and
  2. Drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for important intellectual content; and
  3. Final approval of the version to be published; and
  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including its accuracy and integrity.

All individuals designated as authors must meet all four criteria above. Individuals who contributed to the research or manuscript but do not meet the full criteria for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately.

1.2 Contributorship

Contributors who do not meet the authorship requirements should be listed in the acknowledgment section, with their specific contributions described where appropriate.

1.3 Corresponding Author

The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all listed authors have approved the manuscript, agreed to its submission, and are aware of the journal’s peer review and publication procedures, including any applicable publication fees.

1.4 Changes in Authorship

Any request to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be justified in writing and approved by all authors concerned, including any authors being added or removed. Such changes may only be made before publication and are subject to editorial approval. Requests after publication will be considered only in exceptional cases and may require a formal correction notice.

1.5 Artificial Intelligence (AI)-Assisted Technology

Authors must disclose any use of AI-assisted technologies, including large language models, chatbots, grammar tools, and image generators, in the preparation of the manuscript. The disclosure must specify:

  1. The name of the AI tool used;
  2. The purpose of its use; and
  3. How the tool was used in the research or manuscript preparation.

This disclosure must appear in the cover letter and, where relevant, in the manuscript itself. If AI was used for language editing, this may be stated in the acknowledgment section. If AI was used for data analysis, content generation, or figure production, its use must be described in the methods section or another relevant part of the manuscript.

AI tools must not be listed as authors because they cannot assume responsibility for the originality, validity, and integrity of the work. Full responsibility for the manuscript remains with the human authors. Authors must carefully review and verify all AI-assisted outputs and ensure that no plagiarism, fabricated information, or misleading content is included.

2. Conditions for Submission: Plagiarism, Self-Plagiarism, Duplicate, and Preprint Submissions

Relations: Journal of Media Studies and Public Relations only considers original and unpublished scholarly work. Submission of a manuscript implies that it has not been published elsewhere and is not under review by another journal, book publisher, or proceedings outlet, unless clearly disclosed and permitted by journal policy.

2.1 Plagiarism and Self-Plagiarism

Plagiarism includes the use of another person’s ideas, words, data, or findings without proper attribution. Self-plagiarism refers to the substantial reuse of one’s own previously published material without proper citation or disclosure. Both are considered serious violations of publication ethics.

All manuscripts may be screened using plagiarism detection software before peer review and at later editorial stages if necessary.

Similarity Requirement

  • The overall similarity index should normally be below 20%.
  • Manuscripts exceeding this threshold may be rejected or returned to the authors for revision and clarification.

2.2 Duplicate or Redundant Publication

Duplicate or redundant publication occurs when substantially similar content is submitted or published in more than one venue without appropriate disclosure, citation, or editorial permission. If part of the manuscript has appeared previously, including in another language, conference proceeding, or institutional publication, authors must disclose this clearly at the time of submission.

2.3 Preprint Policy

Authors may deposit their Author’s Original Manuscript (AOM) on a non-commercial preprint server before or during submission, provided that such posting does not transfer copyright and that the manuscript is not under formal publication elsewhere. Authors must disclose the existence of the preprint at submission and provide the relevant citation or link.

Once the article is published in the journal, authors are encouraged to update the preprint record by adding the citation and link to the final published version.

3. Peer Review Process

The journal applies a double-blind peer review process in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another. All submissions are first assessed by the editorial team for suitability, originality, academic quality, and compliance with the journal’s scope and author guidelines.

Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are sent to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on originality, relevance, theoretical or methodological rigor, clarity of presentation, analytical strength, and contribution to media studies and public relations scholarship.

Based on the reviewers’ recommendations, the editorial decision may be:

  1. Accepted;
  2. Accepted with Minor Revisions;
  3. Revised and Resubmitted; or
  4. Rejected.

The Editor-in-Chief or assigned editor makes the final decision on publication. Editors and reviewers must maintain confidentiality throughout the process and disclose any conflict of interest that may affect their judgment.

4. Handling Complaints and Appeals

The journal follows COPE guidance in handling complaints about the editorial process, publication ethics, or peer review, as well as appeals against editorial decisions.

Authors who wish to appeal a decision should submit a reasoned appeal letter to the Editor-in-Chief through the journal system. The appeal should clearly explain:

  1. Why the author disagrees with the editorial decision;
  2. Any specific points in the reviewers’ or editors’ comments that require reconsideration;
  3. Any relevant additional information or evidence; and
  4. Any suspected procedural irregularity or conflict of interest.

Appeals will be reviewed carefully and, where necessary, may involve consultation with additional independent reviewers or editorial board members. The final decision of the journal on the appeal is binding.

5. Conflict of Interest and Competing Interests

To maintain transparency and fairness in scholarly publishing, the journal requires authors, reviewers, and editors to disclose any actual or potential conflict of interest that could influence the submission, review, editorial handling, or publication of a manuscript.

  • Authors must disclose any financial, institutional, personal, political, or professional relationship that may influence the interpretation of their work.
  • Reviewers must decline to review any manuscript in which they have a conflict of interest or any relationship that may compromise their objectivity.
  • Editors must recuse themselves from handling any submission in which they have a conflict of interest.

If an undisclosed conflict of interest is identified before or after publication, the journal may take appropriate action, including correction, expression of concern, or retraction, depending on the seriousness of the case.

6. Data Sharing and Reproducibility

The journal encourages authors to support transparency and reproducibility by making relevant research materials available whenever possible, including datasets, instruments, coding frameworks, appendices, and supplementary files.

  • Authors are encouraged to provide access to data that support the findings of the study, where ethical and legal conditions permit.
  • If data cannot be shared due to confidentiality, privacy, copyright, or security concerns, authors should clearly state the reasons.
  • Authors are encouraged to include a Data Availability Statement describing whether and how the data can be accessed.

7. Ethical Oversight

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their research complies with applicable ethical standards, laws, and institutional policies. Research involving human participants, interviews, surveys, focus groups, or identifiable personal data must be conducted with appropriate ethical safeguards.

7.1 Statement of Informed Consent

Research involving human participants must obtain informed consent from participants or their legal guardians where required. Identifying information must not be published unless it is essential to the research and explicit written permission has been obtained.

7.2 Human Rights and Participant Protection

Authors must ensure that all procedures involving human participants comply with relevant institutional, national, and international ethical standards. If ethical approval was required, the manuscript should state the name of the approving body and, where applicable, the approval number.

8. Intellectual Property, Copyright, and Licensing Policy

8.1 Intellectual Property and Copyright

  • Authors retain copyright in their work.
  • Authors confirm that the submitted manuscript is their original work and does not infringe the rights of any third party.
  • Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce copyrighted material, including tables, figures, images, and substantial text excerpts.
  • All unpublished manuscripts, revisions, and editorial communications remain confidential throughout the editorial process.

8.2 License

8.3 Reporting Violations

Any suspected violation of copyright, licensing, or intellectual property rights should be reported to the Editor-in-Chief for review and appropriate action.

9. Post-Publication Discussion and Corrections

The journal supports academic integrity by allowing appropriate post-publication discussion and by issuing corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern when necessary.

9.1 Post-Publication Comments

Constructive scholarly comments on published articles may be considered by the editorial team and, where appropriate, communicated to the authors for response.

9.2 Corrections

If an error is identified after publication that affects the accuracy, clarity, or interpretation of the article, the journal may publish a correction notice.

9.3 Retractions

A published article may be retracted if there is clear evidence of major error, fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, unethical research, or other serious violations of publication ethics.

9.4 Expressions of Concern

If serious concerns arise regarding a published article but the available evidence is inconclusive, the journal may publish an expression of concern while the matter is under investigation.

All corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern will be issued transparently and in accordance with accepted ethical publishing standards.